Lumpsum vs Periodic Investment Calculator
Compare a one-time lump sum investment against periodic contributions using the same return rate and time horizon. See invested amount, final value, gains, CAGR, and wealth multiple.
Inputs
Verdict
Chart
Lumpsum vs Periodic Investment Calculator
A lumpsum vs periodic investment calculator helps you compare two popular investment approaches using the same return rate and time horizon. While different countries use different terms—such as SIP, DCA, monthly investment, or regular investment—the underlying concept remains the same.
This calculator shows how investment timing and contribution pattern affect long-term wealth, even when the assumed rate of return is identical.
What Is a Lumpsum Investment?
A lumpsum investment (also written as lump sum) is a one-time investment made at the beginning of the investment period. The entire amount remains invested for the full duration and benefits from compound growth from day one.
- One-time capital deployment
- Maximum exposure to compounding from the start
- Results are highly sensitive to when you invest
Lumpsum investments tend to perform well when markets rise steadily over the long term and when the investor has surplus capital available upfront.
What Is a Periodic Investment (SIP / DCA / Regular Investment)?
A periodic investment involves investing a fixed amount at regular intervals—typically monthly. In different regions, this approach is known by different names.
- SIP (Systematic Investment Plan)
- DCA (Dollar Cost Averaging)
- Monthly investment
- Regular investment
Regardless of the name, the idea is the same: money is invested gradually over time.
- Smaller, repeated contributions
- Lower sensitivity to market timing
- Capital is deployed progressively
Periodic investments are especially useful when income is earned regularly and when market volatility is a concern.
Lumpsum vs Periodic Investment: The Core Difference
The key difference between lumpsum and periodic investing is when the money enters the market.
- In a lumpsum investment, all capital is invested immediately.
- In a periodic investment, capital is invested gradually.
This difference alone can produce very different outcomes, even if the total invested amount is similar, the return rate is identical, and the investment duration is the same. This calculator isolates that effect clearly.
When Is Lumpsum Investment Better?
A lumpsum investment tends to work better when:
- You already have a large amount of capital available
- The investment horizon is long (15–20+ years)
- Markets deliver steady long-term growth
- You are comfortable with short-term volatility
Because the entire amount is invested upfront, compounding has more time to work. Over long durations, this can result in significantly higher wealth creation.
When Is SIP / Periodic Investment Better?
A periodic investment often works better when:
- Capital is built gradually from income
- Market timing is uncertain
- Emotional discipline is important
- The investment horizon is long
Even though each contribution is smaller, the total amount invested over time can become much larger, which can outweigh the advantage of early compounding from a lumpsum.
How a Small SIP Can Beat a Large Lumpsum Over Time
This is where many investors are surprised. Consider this simplified scenario:
- One-time investment: ₹1,00,000 (or equivalent)
- Periodic investment: ₹1,000 per month
- Investment duration: 20 years
- Same annual return rate for both
What happens over time?
- The lumpsum investment grows only on the initial ₹1,00,000.
- The periodic investment keeps adding new money every month for 20 years.
- Over 20 years, ₹1,000 per month adds up to ₹2,40,000 invested.
Despite starting smaller, the periodic investor invests more total capital, benefits from compounding on each contribution, and often ends with a higher final value.
This is why a small, consistent periodic investment can outperform a seemingly large one-time investment over long periods.
Why CAGR Looks Lower for Periodic Investments
Many users notice that periodic investments often show a lower CAGR, yet they may still produce a higher final value.
This happens because:
- Money is invested at different times
- Later contributions have less time to compound
- CAGR reflects timing, not just growth
A lower CAGR does not automatically mean worse outcomes—it simply reflects gradual capital deployment.
What This Calculator Helps You Understand
Using this lumpsum vs periodic investment calculator, you can:
- Compare outcomes under identical assumptions
- See how contribution timing affects growth
- Understand why periodic investing can win despite lower CAGR
- Make sense of long-term compounding behavior
The tool does not recommend one approach over the other. Instead, it shows how each strategy behaves mathematically over time.
Lumpsum or SIP: Which One Should You Choose?
There is no universally “better” option.
- Lumpsum investing favors early capital and patience
- Periodic investing favors consistency and long horizons
The right choice depends on:
- How you earn and deploy money
- Your comfort with market volatility
- Your investment duration
This calculator exists to help you see the difference clearly, not to make decisions for you.
Frequently asked questions
When is SIP or periodic investment better than a lumpsum investment?▼
Why does SIP result in a higher final value than lumpsum in this example?▼
If lumpsum has a higher CAGR, why does SIP still end higher?▼
Does this mean SIP is always better than lumpsum?▼
What matters more for long-term wealth: investing early or investing more over time?▼
Conclusion
The debate between lumpsum vs SIP vs periodic investment is ultimately about timing, consistency, and compounding.
A one-time investment benefits from early exposure, while a periodic investment benefits from continued capital addition. Over long durations, even a small monthly investment can surpass a large one-time amount.
Use this calculator to explore different scenarios and understand how time and contribution behavior shape long-term wealth.